• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Homepage
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Submission Instructions
  • Editorial Calendar
Amstat News

Amstat News

The Membership Magazine of the American Statistical Association

  • Printed Issues
  • Practical Significance Podcast
  • Additional Features
  • Columns
  • Member News
  • Departments
You are here: Home / Featured Stories / Reviewing Results from the 2009 JSM Presenter Satisfaction Survey

Reviewing Results from the 2009 JSM Presenter Satisfaction Survey

May 13, 2010 Leave a Comment

In general, satisfaction was high. Overall, 45% said they were very satisfied with the session type and role. Strong satisfaction was most common among presenters at invited and topic-contributed (TC) sessions (other than the discussants). Only 25% of poster presenters were so satisfied with the experience that they are very likely to give future poster presentations. Obviously, this does not bode well for efforts to boost voluntary choice of the poster presentation format unless the poster experience is somehow improved.

Although the results about strong satisfaction seem clear enough, the results about strong dissatisfaction are in the ticklish zone of rare outcomes observed on modest sample sizes. For example, even for the large columns of invited/TC papers and poster presentations, the question arises of whether strong dissatisfaction is more common among the latter than the former. Our colleague Sujit Ghosh from North Carolina State University was inspired by this table to conduct a fully hierarchical Bayesian analysis with vague priors. It looks like a great example of what I have seen Andrew Gelman urging at meetings of advisory panels to the Institute of Education Sciences. Ghosh’s graph is shown in Figure 1. From this, we see clearly that:

  • Session type 1 presenters (invited and topic contributed) have higher levels of strong satisfaction and lower levels of indifferent satisfaction than the other groups. (The middle level of the three-level satisfaction scale: satisfied enough that he/she might try giving future presentations of this type again. Refers in the figure to points with a 2 in the second position.)
  • Session type 4 presenters (regular contributed) have lower levels of strong satisfaction and higher levels of indifferent satisfaction than the other groups.
  • Session type 5 presenters (poster) have much lower levels of strong satisfaction and much higher levels of indifferent satisfaction than the other groups.
  • The satisfaction of type 2 and type 3 presenters is the most uncertain, with wide error bands.
  • Strong dissatisfaction is rare.


Figure 1. Presenter satisfaction by presentation type. (Presentation types 1 through 5 correspond to the columns of Table 1, respectively, and are the first number in each set of square brackets. The second number in each set of square brackets refers to the rows of Table 1, respectively.)


What is less clear to the eye from the figure is whether strong dissatisfaction among poster presenters is really stronger than in other groups. The shrinkage procedure has brought the levels closer together across session types, and the error bands seem fairly wide. However, in a supplemental communication, Ghosh reports the posterior probability of p[5,1]>p[1,1] is virtually one (to be more exact it is 0.9946), so I think we can conclude with fair certainty that we need to somehow improve the poster presentation experience if we are to succeed in persuading more people to convert to posters.

Table 2 shows how satisfaction varies by experience. Repeat presenters are much more likely to present very strong satisfaction than first-time presenters. No doubt, repeat presenters who were not pleased with their first experience screened themselves out from repeat experiences. Perhaps this indicates that we need to give a better idea to first-time presenters of what to expect from the experience. Table 3 contrasts the distributions of presentation types across first-time and repeat presenters. Repeat presenters are much more likely to be giving invited and topic-contributed talks and much less likely to be giving regular contributed talks or to be presenting posters.




Pages: Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4

Filed Under: Featured Stories, Meetings Tagged With: Gelman, JSM2009, presenters

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Search

More to See

A brown-skinned man with short dark hair, glasses, and a short beard in a zip-up sweatshirt

New Member Spotlight: Bilal Shaikh

November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

A dark-skinned man poses in front of two statues

Member Showcase: Arun Chind: An Interdisciplinary Journey Through Statistics, Medicine, Economics, and Law

November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

A white woman with blonde hair wearing a maroon shirt poses outside

ASA Founders Award Recipient Alex Hanlon: A Career Built on Collaboration

November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

A woman with long dark hair wearing glasses smiles

AAAS Mass Media Fellow Lauren Chan: Advancing Evidence-Based Science Through Storytelling

November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

Join SIAM now and get 25% off. SIAM membership includes thousands of app;ied mathematicians and computational and data scientists working in academia, industry, government, and labs. Get 25% off regular membership prices when you join by Dec. 31, 2026 and enter promo code MBNW27AT
Thank you Stata for sponsoring the November issue of practical significance.
Sign up to become a MentorLink Mentor. Through MentorLink, ASA members can connect with mentees looking for guidance, perspecitve, and support as they navigate their careers.

ASA HOME

American Statistical Association

Communications from the Executive Director

ASA Leader Hub

ASA Career Connect

STAFF LIST

Kim Gilliam
Naomi Friedman
Amanda Malloy
Kristin Mohebbi

Archives

Categories

Footer

Editorial Staff

Managing Editor
Megan Murphy

Graphic Designers / Production Coordinators
Olivia Brown
Meg Ruyle

Communications Strategist
Val Nirala

Advertising Manager
Christina Bonner

Contributing Staff Members
Kim Gilliam

American Statistical Association
277 South Washington Street, Suite 370
Alexandria, VA 22314-3646
Phone: (703) 302-1857

 

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in