• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Homepage
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Submission Instructions
  • Editorial Calendar
Amstat News

Amstat News

The Membership Magazine of the American Statistical Association

  • Printed Issues
  • Practical Significance Podcast
  • Additional Features
  • Columns
  • Member News
  • Departments
You are here: Home / Departments / A Statistician's View / A Case Study in Publication Practices: Full House Modeling 

A Case Study in Publication Practices: Full House Modeling 

November 3, 2025 Leave a Comment

Daniel J. Eck 

David Banks is right to question whether our journals and publication processes still serve the profession. My experience with Full House Modeling illustrates both the limitations of the current system and the possibilities of a more modern approach. 

The relevance of this work was obvious well before the journal article appeared in print. By hosting interactive results and producing public-facing narratives, we attracted an early audience of baseball fans and analysts. That audience elevated the project to Tom Tango, a leading voice in MLB analytics, who validated the work publicly. 

Soon after, Foolish Baseball, a YouTube channel with more than 350,000 subscribers, featured the research in a video essay. All this happened before the Annals of Applied Statistics’ print edition was released. 

Meanwhile, the journal process was slow. After more than a year under review, the Journal of the American Statistical Association ultimately rejected the paper. AOAS then handled the work efficiently and provided the necessary anchor of credibility. But pre-publication momentum was already underway. A University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign  press release pointed to the interdisciplinary publication along with the Foolish Baseball feature, which in turn enabled a front-page New York Times science article  just two months after AOAS published our paper. The Institute of Mathematical Statistics later amplified that feature on social media.  

This sequence reflects what Banks describes: Refereeing is inconsistent, and journals remain constrained by outdated models that undervalue modern communication. In contrast, interactive tools, video essays, and early institutional press channels recognized and validated the work quickly, ultimately carrying it into public dialogue. Yet across nearly three years of review at both AOAS and JASA, the peer-review process largely overlooked these public-facing aspects (though the AOAS reviewers did engage closely with public-facing technical reports). If statistics wants to remain relevant, our publication practices must evolve. Otherwise, we risk that broadly impactful contributions will be recognized more widely outside our journals than within them. 

Filed Under: A Statistician's View, Departments Tagged With: A statistician's view, Full House Modeling, journals, public-facing, Publications

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Search

More to See

A brown-skinned man with short dark hair, glasses, and a short beard in a zip-up sweatshirt

New Member Spotlight: Bilal Shaikh

November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

A dark-skinned man poses in front of two statues

Member Showcase: Arun Chind: An Interdisciplinary Journey Through Statistics, Medicine, Economics, and Law

November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

A white woman with blonde hair wearing a maroon shirt poses outside

ASA Founders Award Recipient Alex Hanlon: A Career Built on Collaboration

November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

A woman with long dark hair wearing glasses smiles

AAAS Mass Media Fellow Lauren Chan: Advancing Evidence-Based Science Through Storytelling

November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

Join SIAM now and get 25% off. SIAM membership includes thousands of app;ied mathematicians and computational and data scientists working in academia, industry, government, and labs. Get 25% off regular membership prices when you join by Dec. 31, 2026 and enter promo code MBNW27AT
Thank you Stata for sponsoring the November issue of practical significance.
Sign up to become a MentorLink Mentor. Through MentorLink, ASA members can connect with mentees looking for guidance, perspecitve, and support as they navigate their careers.

ASA HOME

American Statistical Association

Communications from the Executive Director

ASA Leader Hub

ASA Career Connect

STAFF LIST

Kim Gilliam
Naomi Friedman
Amanda Malloy
Kristin Mohebbi

Archives

Categories

Footer

Editorial Staff

Managing Editor
Megan Murphy

Graphic Designers / Production Coordinators
Olivia Brown
Meg Ruyle

Communications Strategist
Val Nirala

Advertising Manager
Christina Bonner

Contributing Staff Members
Kim Gilliam

American Statistical Association
277 South Washington Street, Suite 370
Alexandria, VA 22314-3646
Phone: (703) 302-1857

 

Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in