• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Homepage
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Submission Instructions
  • Editorial Calendar
Amstat News

Amstat News

The Membership Magazine of the American Statistical Association

  • Printed Issues
  • Practical Significance Podcast
  • Additional Features
  • Columns
  • Member News
  • Departments
You are here: Home / Additional Features / Previous Features / National Research Council’s Evaluation of VIGRE Program Released

National Research Council’s Evaluation of VIGRE Program Released

May 13, 2010 Leave a Comment

William E. Kirwan, Mark L. Green, and Neal D. Glassman


This article originally appeared in the March 2010 issue of the American Mathematical Society’s newsletter

Notices.

In the 1980s and 1990s, there was concern within the mathematical sciences community that postsecondary education in the mathematical sciences was in trouble. A series of challenges was identified in important national reports, including in particular the following:

  • “Renewing U.S. Mathematics: Critical Resource for the Future” (1984), also known as the David Report after the chair of the committee, former presidential science advisor Edward David
  • “Educating Mathematical Scientists: Doctoral Study and the Postdoctoral Experience in the United States” (1992), also known as the Douglas Report after committee chair Ronald Douglas
  • The report of an international panel convened by the National Science Foundation, “Report of the Senior Assessment Panel for the International Assessment of the U.S. Mathematical Sciences” (1998)(PDF), also known as the Odom Report after panel chair General William Odom


Members of the Committee to Evaluate the National Science Foundation’s Vertically Integrated Grants for Research and Education (VIGRE) program were:
William E. Kirwan (chair)

    Efraim Armendariz

      John A. Burns

        C. Herbert Clemens

          Dona L. Crawford

            Cristine M. Cumming

              Lawrence Craig Evans

                Charles L. Fefferman

                  Martin Golubitsky

                    Mark L. Green

                      Leo P. Kadanoff

                        Daniel L. Solomon

                          Lynn Arthur Steen

                            Karen L. Vogtmann

                              Eric W. Welch

                                Shmuel Winograd

                                  Together, these reports painted a picture for the mathematical sciences that focused on three major challenges: inadequate funding, insufficient numbers of students interested in mathematics, and shortcomings in the shape and direction of postsecondary mathematics education.

                                  Student Issues

                                  These reports raised four issues concerning students: (1) the number of students receiving degrees, (2) the lack of racial and gender diversity among the mathematics graduate student body, (3) the declining fraction of U.S. citizens receiving advanced degrees in mathematics, and (4) the lack of sufficient postdoctoral fellowships for new doctorates.

                                  Four issues were identified with respect to the structure of training in the mathematical sciences: (1) increasing the breadth, (2) providing a better balance of education and research, (3) decreasing the time to degree, and (4) creating a more positive learning experience.

                                  In response to all these concerns, Donald Lewis, then director of the Division of Mathematical Sciences (DMS) at the National Science Foundation (NSF), wrote a “dear colleague” letter to the mathematical sciences community, based on recommendations of a DMS special emphasis panel, which introduced and justified the Grants for the Vertical Integration of Research and Education in the Mathematical Sciences (VIGRE) program.

                                  The panel recommended that the VIGRE program enable departments to carry out innovative educational programs at levels beyond then-current department resources. The panel also saw the program achieving a change of culture in departments, resulting in broadening opportunities through new curriculum development and research experiences. Although the goals of the VIGRE program have changed from year to year, they have consistently included

                                  • integration of research and education
                                  • enhanced interaction across undergraduates, graduates, postdoctoral fellows, and faculty
                                    broadened educational experiences of students to include workforce and early research opportunities
                                  • more students motivated to study mathematics and statistics

                                  VIGRE has been a continuing DMS program since 1999, but it had not been externally evaluated until NSF, in 2007, requested the appointment of a committee of the National Research Council’s (NRC’s) Board on Mathematical Sciences and Their Applications. The charge to this committee included the evaluation of past and current practices for steering and assessing the VIGRE program and recommendations on how to improve it.

                                  At about the same time, NSF also commissioned a report, “Increasing the Quantity and Quality of the Mathematical Sciences Workforce Through Vertical Integration of Cultural Change,” by Margaret Cozzens. This report recounts some successes of the VIGRE program but is not meant to be a formal evaluation.

                                  Pages: Page 1 Page 2 Page 3

                                  Filed Under: Previous Features Tagged With: AMS, Mathematical, NSF, Sciences, VIGRE

                                  Reader Interactions

                                  Leave a Reply Cancel reply

                                  Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

                                  Primary Sidebar

                                  Search

                                  More to See

                                  A brown-skinned man with short dark hair, glasses, and a short beard in a zip-up sweatshirt

                                  New Member Spotlight: Bilal Shaikh

                                  November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

                                  A dark-skinned man poses in front of two statues

                                  Member Showcase: Arun Chind: An Interdisciplinary Journey Through Statistics, Medicine, Economics, and Law

                                  November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

                                  A white woman with blonde hair wearing a maroon shirt poses outside

                                  ASA Founders Award Recipient Alex Hanlon: A Career Built on Collaboration

                                  November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

                                  A woman with long dark hair wearing glasses smiles

                                  AAAS Mass Media Fellow Lauren Chan: Advancing Evidence-Based Science Through Storytelling

                                  November 2, 2026 By Meg Ruyle

                                  Join SIAM now and get 25% off. SIAM membership includes thousands of app;ied mathematicians and computational and data scientists working in academia, industry, government, and labs. Get 25% off regular membership prices when you join by Dec. 31, 2026 and enter promo code MBNW27AT
                                  Thank you Stata for sponsoring the November issue of practical significance.
                                  Sign up to become a MentorLink Mentor. Through MentorLink, ASA members can connect with mentees looking for guidance, perspecitve, and support as they navigate their careers.

                                  ASA HOME

                                  American Statistical Association

                                  Communications from the Executive Director

                                  ASA Leader Hub

                                  ASA Career Connect

                                  STAFF LIST

                                  Kim Gilliam
                                  Naomi Friedman
                                  Amanda Malloy
                                  Kristin Mohebbi

                                  Archives

                                  Categories

                                  Footer

                                  Editorial Staff

                                  Managing Editor
                                  Megan Murphy

                                  Graphic Designers / Production Coordinators
                                  Olivia Brown
                                  Meg Ruyle

                                  Communications Strategist
                                  Val Nirala

                                  Advertising Manager
                                  Christina Bonner

                                  Contributing Staff Members
                                  Kim Gilliam

                                  American Statistical Association
                                  277 South Washington Street, Suite 370
                                  Alexandria, VA 22314-3646
                                  Phone: (703) 302-1857

                                   

                                  Copyright © 2026 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in